re: Bad cast albums
Posted by: Chromolume 01:01 pm EDT 06/25/24
In reply to: re: Bad cast albums - EvFoDr 12:28 pm EDT 06/25/24

Yes, though it's only the last section of the song, so it might have felt like it was tagged on to the recording. They probably thought, for the album's sake, that "You And I" made a better ending.

But I had a similar kind of experience with Dreamgirls. The way that "One Night Only" works on the album, with the song literally stolen from Effie as the arrangement continues, is so dramatic. But it doesn't happen quite that way (musically speaking) in the show (there's a scene inbetween). Damn. But it's a wonderful coup de theatre on the recording.

I've always been disappointed in the ending on the OBCR of Cabaret, where they substituted vocals of "Meeskite" and "So What" instead of the dialogue that actually happens, with the music just as underscoring. I think the dialogue as written in those spots would have told the story infinitely better.
reply

Previous: re: Bad cast albums - EvFoDr 12:28 pm EDT 06/25/24
Next: re: Bad cast albums - lanky 11:35 am EDT 06/25/24
Thread:


    Time to render: 0.012851 seconds.