Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Phoenix

God's Favorite
Don Bluth Front Row Theatre

Also see Gil's reviews of Love, Sex and the I.R.S., Menopause the Musical and Anything Goes


Tom Endicott and Gary Caswell
Neil Simon has had a very prolific career. He has written over thirty plays, been awarded with the Tony and the Pulitzer Prize, and most of his plays had successful Broadway runs. However, a few of his plays weren't exactly hits and two theatre companies in town have chosen two of Simon's less successful plays as recent presentations. Brelby just closed their production of the fun fable Fools and Don Bluth Front Row Theatre just opened God's Favorite, from 1974. While God's Favorite may not be as good of a comedy as some of Simon's more well-known plays, it does have some fun moments, and the cast and direction for the Don Bluth production are quite good.

Set in a large house on Long Island, the play tells the story of wealthy businessman Joe Benjamin and his family. Benjamin is visited late one night by a messenger of God named Sidney who claims that Joe is God's "favorite." Due to a bet that God made with the Devil, Joe will now be forced to face many obstacles as a way to get him to renounce God. God has faith in Joe that he won't give in, but the many afflictions that are thrown his way make it seem like he just might start to question his faith.

While the comedy has plenty of Simon's typical wit and a nice mix of well-written characters, the premise and plot are fairly monotonous and not really much actually happens during the play. Fortunately, this production has a fun cast that dives right in, and director Gary Caswell, who also portrays Sidney, keeps the action moving along briskly and derives fine performances from his cast.

As Joe, Tom Endicott has the right level of determination to get through whatever is thrown his way, even while he has to deal with his crazy family in doing so. He shows great strength and courage with what he is tested with. Caswell brings an appropriate sense of charm to the role of God's messenger, though when charm doesn't work he is more than happy to resort to other means. Caswell balances the many nuances of the role well. Cheryl Schaar is a joy as Joe's suffering wife.

Technical aspects are quite good, with Curtis Watson's lighting design providing nice imagery for the many nighttime scenes and Roger McKay's sound design delivering some intense lighting effects. Corinne Hawkin's costumes are appropriate for the characters, though Caswell's set is fairly basic—mainly just an assortment of chairs and a sofa that aren't quite at the expensive, high-end level that the script calls fr.

While God's Favorite may not be one of Simon's best works, there is a nice morality tale at the center of the story, and this production has good acting and direction and some impressive creative aspects. Also, the small theatre space provides a nice amount of intimacy and immediacy, and the overall technical aspects of the venue are quite impressive.

God's Favorite runs at the Don Bluth Front Row Theatre, 8670 East Shea Blvd. Scottsdale, through April 3rd, 2015. For more information on this production or to order tickets, visit www.donbluthfrontrowtheatre.com or call 480 314-0841.

Director: Gary Caswell
Set Design: Gary Caswell
Lighting Design: Curtis Watson
Sound Design: Roger McKay
Costume Designer: Corinne Hawkins
Props: Gary Caswell

Cast:
Joseph Benjamin: Tom Endicott
Sidney Lipton: Gary Caswell
Rose Benjamin: Cheryl Schaar
David Benjamin: Ed Como
Ben Benjamin: Jordan Davis
Sara Benjamin: Kellie Dunlap
Morris: Frank Aaron
Mady: Corinne Hawkins


Photo: Mike Rolfe

--Gil Benbrook


Also see the Current Theatre Season Calendar for Phoenix